CENTER FOR ETHICS AND THE RULE OF LAW​

Supreme Court’s Trump immunity decision a ‘blow against accountability for presidents’

Share this Post

Related posts

CERL Interns Natalie Davidson and David Pritchard

CERL externs participate in U.S. Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals oral argument

Microphones prepared for the press conference and mic flags displaying fake news logos: disinformation and propaganda concept, blank copy space

How the Trump administration is weaponizing the Communications Act of 1934

CERL’s Professor Claire Finkelstein spoke with media about the Supreme Court’s recent decision to grant former President Donald Trump partial immunity from criminal prosecution on interference charges. The decision, which has essentially “eliminated judicial review for a whole set of presidential actions,” could be disastrous for the accountability of future presidents.

Finkelstein asserts that, according to the ruling, Trump would not only be within his constitutional rights to fire Special Attorney Jack Smith should he be reelected, but that the Courts would not have the power to charge him with obstruction of justice.

“One would think that if you fire a Special Counsel who is prosecuting you, that that would be a prime example of obstruction of justice,” said Finkelstein. “But this decision essentially says that Congress doesn’t have the authority to create statutes that make the president liable for obstruction if it would cut into his core constitutional powers. And it says the Courts don’t have [that] authority.”

“The irony here is that the Supreme Court has actually weakened federal courts.”

Claire Finkelstein is the Algernon Biddle Professor of Law and Professor of Philosophy and Faculty Director of the Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law. Read her bio here. 

WATCH at AL Jazeera

WATCH at Forbes

READ at LA Times

The views expressed here are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent those of any organization or university.

Mailing List

Submissions

A blog covering ethics and rule of law issues in national security, warfare, and democratic governance. The opinions expressed in these posts are those of the writers and do not necessarily represent CERL’s official views.

Please submit to the Rule of Law Post via this form. For additional details on the blog post format, refer to CERL’s submission guidelines. Should your submission be accepted, we ask that you kindly complete the Agreement to Transfer Copyright.

Please upload text in one document under 6 mb. Preferred format as a simple text file (.txt).

Share Supreme Court’s Trump immunity decision a ‘blow against accountability for presidents’ on:

LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
Reddit
Email
Print
Supreme Court’s Trump immunity decision a ‘blow against accountability for presidents’