CENTER FOR ETHICS AND THE RULE OF LAW​

Penn CERL and NIMJ file amicus brief in United States v. Askins urging Court to apply international law lens to “at war” tolling provision 

Share this Post

Related posts

CERL Interns Natalie Davidson and David Pritchard

CERL externs participate in U.S. Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals oral argument

Microphones prepared for the press conference and mic flags displaying fake news logos: disinformation and propaganda concept, blank copy space

How the Trump administration is weaponizing the Communications Act of 1934

Penn’s Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law (CERL) and the National Institute of Military Justice (NIMJ) filed an amicus brief last week with the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces in United States v. Askins, concerning a statute of limitations tolling provision.  

The relevant tolling provision in the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) operates when the United States is “at war.” The brief argues that the lower court did not apply the appropriate test to determine what “at war” means within the statute, and urges the Court to “assess whether the United States was ‘at war’ according to the definition of ‘time of war’ found in the Manual for Courts-Martial interpreted through the lens of international law.” 

Amici assert that the Army Court of Criminal Appeals gave inappropriate weight to factors derived from United States v. Bancroft in determining  whether the United States was “at war” within the meaning of the UCMJ.  International law, specifically the Tadić test, can help resolve ambiguities around the meaning of the phrase “time of war.” 

According to the brief, “In the absence of a clear statement from Congress defining the meaning of the phrase ‘at war,’ reliance on the international consensus of what constitutes an armed conflict is a methodological approach consistent with United States case law.” 

Co-counsel on the brief are Philip D. Cave, chair of NIMJ; Rachel L. Baron, CERL-NIMJ litigation and policy postdoctoral fellow; and Brenner M. Fissell, vice president of NIMJ and distinguished senior fellow at CERL. 

Mailing List

Submissions

A blog covering ethics and rule of law issues in national security, warfare, and democratic governance. The opinions expressed in these posts are those of the writers and do not necessarily represent CERL’s official views.

Please submit to the Rule of Law Post via this form. For additional details on the blog post format, refer to CERL’s submission guidelines. Should your submission be accepted, we ask that you kindly complete the Agreement to Transfer Copyright.

Please upload text in one document under 6 mb. Preferred format as a simple text file (.txt).

Share Penn CERL and NIMJ file amicus brief in United States v. Askins urging Court to apply international law lens to “at war” tolling provision  on:

LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
Reddit
Email
Print
Penn CERL and NIMJ file amicus brief in United States v. Askins urging Court to apply international law lens to “at war” tolling provision