Two student externs at the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law (CERL) participated in an oral argument held by the U.S. Air Force Court of Criminal Appeals (AFCCA) as part of the Appellate Judges Education Institute (AJEI) and its student outreach program. The oral argument took place on November 13, 2026, before a three-judge panel at the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Philadelphia for the case United States v. Staff Sergeant Remington E. Carlisle (No. ACM 40784).
The case involves an Air Force staff sergeant who was charged with possession, viewing, and distribution of child pornography under Article 134 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice. After the case was remanded to the trial court by the AFCCA, Staff Sergeant Carlise pleaded guilty to possessing child pornography. The brief and oral arguments prepared by CERL’s externs pertain to the legality and constitutionality of the trial judge’s acceptance of the plea agreement.
Under the supervision of CERL’s Distinguished Senior Fellow, Brenner Fissell, CERL externs Natalie Davidson and David Pritchard, both law students at Penn Carey Law and former CERL interns (Summer ‘26), participated as amicus curiae on behalf of the appellee the United States government.
The students’ participation also included filing an amicus brief in the case chosen for their oral argument. The brief made two central arguments. The first is that the military judge did not abuse his discretion in accepting the plea since the record establishes a provident plea. The second argument is the military judge did not abuse his discretion in accepting the plea because the possession of the pornographic material on the internet is not constitutionally protected. A link to the brief is included below.
“It was an amazing experience, especially being my first time arguing in a real court. Being in the presence of experienced military lawyers and watching them present their arguments was inspiring, and I really appreciate that the AFCCA conducts this student outreach program,” said Natalie Davidson about her experiences writing the brief and participating in oral argument on behalf of the appellee, the United States government. “After spending so much time writing our side’s brief, it was particularly meaningful to hear the judges and lawyers reference the case law we had discussed during the argument. It felt like our work was making an impact.”
“The AFCCA’s Project Outreach gave us a rare opportunity to prepare a briefing from a perspective that many law students never encounter,” said David Pritchard about continuing to work with CERL and how this experience has strengthened his oral advocacy skills. “Military appellate practice operates within its own framework of statutes, rules, and precedent, and working within that framework required us to approach familiar legal questions in a new way. We had to learn the court’s procedures and the unique considerations that shape its decisions, and then translate that understanding into persuasive written advocacy.”
“AFCCA’s Project Outreach provided an invaluable opportunity for CERL interns to argue a real case in front of real lawyers and judges,” said Distinguished Senior Fellow Brenner Fissell about the program. “The interns also provided an amicus brief that will add substantial value to the court when it is deliberating.”
CERL congratulates its student externs and all participants in the oral argument as part of the student outreach program!